Swayze Express derails Richmond

I like Casey Janssen. He’s a good pitcher, he seems like a good guy, he’s got a great nickname (Dirty!) and that led Squizz (the other poster on this site and a contributor to a great soccer site) to name Dirty’s fastball the Swayze Express.

How can you not like a pitcher who can throw the Swayze Express?

No, I don’t have a problem with Janssen. What I have a problem with is how the Jays are using the man called Dirty.

This may be a bit of an unpopular opinion after Dirty’s solid performance Monday night against the Texas Rangers of Arlington, but Janssen should be working out of the bullpen, not the rotation. Just take a look at his career splits.

As a starter, Janssen’s ERA is 5.23, with a WHIP of 1.381 and batters have gone .286/.335/.453/.788. Working out of the pen, Janssen’s numbers are dirty: 2.27 ERA, 1.221 WHIP and batters have gone .253/.308/.354/.662 against him. It’s pretty clear that, over his career, Janssen’s been a lot more effective out of the pen.

This is not to say that he’s not useful in the rotation, but with some of the difficulties that the pen has had in the last little while and the fact that Brett Cecil, Bobby Ray, David Purcey and Fabio Castro could all step into the rotation (not to mention a certain 305-game winner who just happens to be looking for a team) maybe the Jays would be better served with Janssen being the dominant 1-2 inning guy he was before getting injured.

The other problem I have with how Janssen’s being used is what it’s doing to Captain Canada. Before Dirty’s return to the big club, Scott Richmond was being called the de facto No. 2 starter on the team by better-known bloggers than myself.

After Dirty’s return, Richmond went from being de facto No. 2 (and doing a pretty good of it) to being a spare part. Saturday’s game was not what you might expect from a former de facto No. 2, but it was also Richmond’s first start since May 24. That’s nearly two weeks between starts, and he only made one relief appearance in between. How can you expect a guy to be spot on when he’s getting so little time on the mound?

Also, why would you throw him out there after two weeks to face a lineup in which six of the hitters would be facing him from the left side? If Richmond’s got a real weakness, it’s that he’s not so good at handling lefty-dominated lineups.

What I really want to know is what happened to make Cito seemingly lose faith in Richmond? For a guy who’s showing a frustratingly unbelievable amount of patience with Vernon Wells (and to a lesser extent, Alex Rios), he sure is quick to turn on his pitchers.

6 thoughts on “Swayze Express derails Richmond

  1. Most of Janssen’s career numbers as a starter came while he was hiding a back injury from the team, so I don’t know if that’s totally representative of his abilities as a starter.

    • I don’t think that’s enough to completely disregard the fact that he’s had better success when working out of the pen, but it’s a fair point nonetheless.

      How about this as a reason for Casey to be a 1-2 inning guy out of the pen: The second time through the lineup this year, teams are hitting him at a .419/.500/.645/1.145 clip.

      Janssen’s considerably more effective the first time through and working as a short relief guy, that’s all he’d have to do.

  2. I came to this comment section to post the same thing Torgen did, but I see he already posted it.. So yes, consider this a +1 to that..

    Casey wasn’t really healthy before when he was a starter …

    Plus, it’s never a bad thing to have TOO many options at starter… You can’t really expect guys like Castro, Cecil,Richmond to be long-term fixes and Janssen is actually the most experienced of the group. I’m okay with giving him more starts for now, as the bullpen should return to form eventually too.

  3. Pingback: Richmond’s back! (too bad it happened like this) « Infield fly

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s